Saturday July 4, 2009
Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
Friday, May 16, 2008 12:22 AM CDT
Postville reels from raid
Hilbana, 1, has been staying at St. Bridget's Catholic Church in Postville since Monday's immigration raid at Agriprocessors. Her mother is from Guatemala but Hilbana is a U.S. citizen. DENNIS MAGEE/Waterloo Courier
POSTVILLE — Monday’s federal immigration raid damaged Postville’s schools, businesses, neighborhoods and the fragile relationships forged between the city’s diverse cultures, upset residents say.

Community members say they don’t understand what the biggest immigration raid on a single site in U.S. history accomplished, if anything.

“Drive around Iowa and there’s a lot of dead towns,” businessman Gabay Menahn said. “Here it’s the same thing, but we’ve got a heart beating — it’s called Agriprocessors. When you take away the heart, the body dies.”

Federal agents arrested 390 workers at Agriprocessors, the nation’s largest kosher meat processing plant.

Many in town dealing with the aftermath on Wednesday said the raid took away fathers and mothers who only wanted to be left alone to support their families and replaced relative harmony in the community with fear and suspicion: Rumors floated through town about unmarked Immigration and Customs Enforcement vehicles on patrol and about car chases and shootings in the wake of the raid.

Volunteers at St. Bridget Catholic Church, where many from the Hispanic community are staying, said many people from the community dropped off food and clothing.

Travis Seibert, a businessman who shares an office with Mehahn, said the population was maturing, replacing young single men — who tend to cause trouble no matter their ethnic origins. In their place in recent years, hardworking Hispanic families had moved in.

“Over the last few years, we got where the plant was a lot more oriented towards families,” he said. “People got along really well. We saw them as neighbors and friends.”

Many of those are gone now, he said.

Before Monday’s raid, Seibert said, the economy in Postville, population 2,300, was strong. Property values were rising.

Postville’s main street had but one vacant building, which opened up only recently.

Some Hispanic storefronts are shuttered, and homes and apartments are abandoned. At GAL Investments, which owns 127 rental units, Menahn said the vacancy rate soared to 75 percent after Monday’s raid. With $50,000 monthly payments to make, the company’s loans must be frozen to avoid bankruptcy, he added.

Some say the town will struggle but eventually recover. Others claim the raid represents a fatal blow.

“Postville is going to go to hell,” Mary Ramos said.

She was picking up the belongings of three friends at an apartment complex in the southeast corner of Postville. She said the trio, exhausted and hungry, arrived on her doorstep Monday night 75 miles away in Dubuque.

“I said, ‘Oh my gosh, what are you doing here?’ They said, ‘We ran. We jumped out of the second-story window and we ran.’ ”

Picking through their personal effects, Ramos told two other women with her to pick up the men’s shoes and see if there was room in the car for a microwave. They cleaned out the refrigerator, but left many other items, including mattresses and folding chairs.

Shuffling through a drawer, Ramos found a few pay stubs. Bold letters on the check read “AGRIPROCESSORS, INC. Thanks You.” Each showed all three men were making within 25 cents of Iowa’s minimum wage.

“Moises was making $7.25 an hour after three years of work,” Ramos said.

After a press conference at St. Bridget’s Church, Sister Mary McCauley said Agriprocessors bears responsibility for helping create the present situation. She cited safety violations, inappropriate working conditions, long hours and claims the company ignored workers’ physical needs.

Despite such allegations, though, many in the community on Wednesday were more likely to blame ICE agents who conducted the raid and politicians who have yet to implement an effective immigration policy.

Dixie Starkey said plenty of the burden should go toward the illegal aliens and the plant’s owners. She was moving into a rental property after she found a home that housed two Hispanic families until Monday. In their rush to leave, the families left behind baby bottles and furniture, which the landlord cleared out.

“They got what they asked for. They came here illegally, and knowing they were here illegally, they bring their families over here illegally,” she said. “Agri knew they were illegals. It’s Agri’s own tough luck, too.”

Even so, Starkey acknowledged the plant’s absence would likely hurt the town, if only temporarily.

“Let’s hope Agri can pick up and go on with what happened,” she said.

Laverne Wedo, 79, a longtime resident, also blamed the illegal workers and plant owners. He said he assumes everyone in town, including the plant’s owners, knew illegal aliens worked in the plant.

“I feel kind of sorry for them in a way, but they should know better, too, I think,” he said. “There’s other ways to get up here. You don’t have to sneak.”

But he also said he liked those in the Mexican community, including three young men who live next door. He hasn’t seen another group of Hispanic men that live in a house across the street; he assumed Wednesday that they had fled the area.

“I didn’t see any lights on last night,” Wedo said.

But the men are still there, said Santiago Salvador, who lives down the street. They’ve been hiding inside since Monday.

“In past days, I’d walk down the street and say hi to my people. Now my neighbors are gone. It’s sad,” he said.

Salvador and his family arrived a month ago from Guatemala on tourist visas. They planned to find jobs once they obtained proper paperwork. Now, they intend to go home, perhaps as soon as this weekend.

Jens Manuel Krogstad and Dennis Magee are reporters for the Waterloo-Cedar Falls Courier, a Lee Enterprises newspaper. Reach him at 319-291-1580 or jens.krogstad@wcfcourier.com.

Archbishop Hanus to celebrate Mass in Postville Saturday

WATERLOO — Dubuque Archbishop Jerome Hanus will celebrate Mass in English and Spanish at St. Bridget Church in Postville Saturday at 4:30 p.m.

Hanus will travel to Postville for the service in the wake of the federal immigration raid at the Agriprocessors meat plant in Postville that resulted in the detention of 390 people.

The Dubuque archdiocese covers the northeast quadrant of Iowa and includes Postville.

“This state of terror for families is evidence that our political system has not adequately addressed the demand for labor, the inadequacies of our present immigration policies and practices, and the broader economic challenges,” the archbishop said earlier this week.

“Some of the weakest members among us are bearing the brunt of the suffering, while legislators and other leaders, as well as many of us in the general public, have failed to give this issue the priority that it deserves,” Hanus said.

 — From the Waterloo Courier

User Comments - 29 comment(s)

Post Your Comments On This Story
*Member ID:
*Password:
 

Click here to create an account.

Please submit your comment only once. Your comment will be posted immediately after submission. By submitting this form you agree to our Comment Policy & Privacy Policy.

Comment Policy: (hide)
Globegazette.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments are moderated periodically and will be deleted if found inappropriate. We will not edit or alter your comments, but will delete those that violate our code of conduct. No comment may contain:
  • Potentially libelous statements; such as accusing somebody of a crime, defamation of character, or statements that can harm somebody's reputation.
  • Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
  • Personal attacks, insults, threats, harassment or inciting violence.
  • Commercial product promotions.
  • Referrals to other Web addresses.
  • E-mail addresses
(hide)
globegazette.com Privacy Policy: (hide)
Welcome to the web sites of the Globe Gazette, a media company located in eastern Iowa. We believe in your right to know what information is collected during your visit to our web sites and how the information is used and safeguarded.

Information Gathered by Voluntary Submission
To make use of certain features on our websites (such as contests, story comments, personalized web pages and other interactive forums) visitors need to register and to provide certain information as part of the registration or participation process. (We may ask, for example, for your name, email address, sex, age, and zip code, and we might request information on your interest in sports, personal finance, the performing arts, and the like.)

The information you supply will help us to offer you more personalized features, to tailor our sites to your interests and make them more useful to you. The more you tell us about yourself, the more value we can offer you. Supplying such information is entirely voluntary. But if you don't supply the information we need, we may be unable to provide you with services we make available to other visitors to our sites. Of course, even if you want to remain completely anonymous, you're still free to take advantage of the wealth of content available on our sites without registration.

Information Automatically Gathered About All Visitors
We collect aggregate and user-specific information on what pages consumers access or visit. This information is used to generate reports that help the Globe Gazette assess the value of and interest in the various web sites. The information we collect is used by us to improve the content of our web page. We can build a better site if we know which pages our users are visiting and how often.

Our web servers automatically collect limited information about your computer's connection to the Internet, including your IP address but not the e-mail address, when you visit our sites. Your IP address does not identify you personally. We use this information to deliver our web pages to you upon request, to tailor our sites to the interests of our users, and to measure traffic within our sites.

To help make our sites more responsive to the needs of our visitors, we may utilize a standard feature of browser software, called a "cookie". The cookie doesn't actually identify the visitor, just the computer that a visitor uses to access our site. A cookie can't read data off your hard drive. Our advertisers or content partners may also assign their own cookies to your browser, a process that we cannot control. We use cookies to help us tailor our site to your needs, to deliver a better, more personalized service. It is a cookie, for example, that allows us to deliver your personalized stock quotes each time you visit a site.

Information Shared With Other Organizations
When we present information to our advertisers -- to help them understand our audience and confirm the value of advertising on our websites -- it is usually in the form of aggregated statistics on traffic to various pages within our sites. We will not share individual user information with third parties unless the user has specifically approved the release of that information.

Special Attention to Children
Children should always get permission from their parents before sending any information about themselves (such as their names, email addresses, and phone numbers) over the Internet, to us or to anyone else. We do not specifically collect information about children. We encourage parents to review and share safety tips with their children participating in the online experience.

A final note:
The Globe Gazette is affiliated with other online companies, some of which feature our branding. This policy statement does not apply to those companies' web sites; please refer to these affiliated sites to obtain information on their privacy policies. If you can't find the privacy policy of any of these sites via a link from the site's homepage, you should contact the site directly for more information.

The Web is an evolving medium. If we need to change our privacy policy at some point in the future, we'll post the changes before they take effect. Of course, our use of information gathered while the current policy is in effect will always be consistent with the current policy, even if we change that policy later.

(hide)

Click here to report offensive or inappropriate comments. Please make sure to identify the comment you're concerned about, the story to which the comment was attached, the date of the comment and the person who made the post.

The Globe Gazette provides our story commenting feature in order to solicit feedback, debate and discussion on topics of local interest. For an explanation of our policy of appropriate postings, please see our Rules of the Road.

Thanks for reading, and thanks for participating.

Rules of the Road: (hide)
Blog administrators and moderators have the right to edit, delete, move or close any comment or forum at any time. The following rules and guidelines clarify our practices and provide an explanation of what content may lead to message deletion and/or user bans.

Play nice: Messages containing intentionally misleading information, defamatory content, threats, verbal abuse, harassment, obscenity or personal information about other individuals are not allowed. Comments should be brief and stick to either generally known facts or the facts contained in a news story. Keep a civil tone. Resist making personal attacks or indulging in name-calling. If your item doesn't get posted or is deleted, tone it down a bit and try again.

Keep your posts commercial-free: Advertisements, chain letters, pyramid schemes and solicitations are unacceptable.

Spam is not allowed: Spamming includes multiple disruptive, meaningless or repetitive messages, or messages posted solely for solicitation. Messages considered spam, trolling or flaming (as determined by the sole discretion of the moderator) can be deleted without warning or explanation.

User Accounts: Registered user names must follow the same rules as forum posts. Any user accounts considered objectionable or created for the purpose of spamming or promoting commercial interests may be deleted. Deliberate or continued abuse of user accounts will result in a ban of the user's IP address.

Signatures: All content posted in the user's signature field must follow the same rules as forum messages and user accounts.

Fair Use: Do not post entire articles into comments or forums. This is a potential violation of copyright laws. It's unnecessary and results in needlessly long posts. Instead, post a brief abstract of the material and a link to the complete source. If you are not sure how much of an article you can legally post, please simply post a link to the material.

Don't see a message you posted earlier? Administrators may move messages to more relevant forums. If you recently posted a message and cannot find it anywhere, the message may have been deleted because of objectionable content. Feel free to try again or contact the moderator for details.

What to do if your account has been banned: If you try to login and receive a message that you've been banned, do not immediately open another user account and continue the inappropriate behavior. Such action could result in a permanent ban. Instead, contact the administrator and find out what caused the sanction. We may or may not reinstate your privileges after such a contact.
(hide)
Showing The Last 29 comment(s) Comments On This Story

ia_strmchsr wrote on May 18, 2008 9:18 PM:

" Rather we like it or not this raid or raids like this are not new. If we would only enforce the laws aready on the books and increase our presence on the borders then raids like what happend in postville would not have to occur.

An interesting read of something that happend in our past.. Operation Wetback.

Operation Wetback was a 1954 project of the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) to remove about 4 million illegal immigrants from the southwestern United States, with a focus on Mexican nationals.

All you have to do is look it up. This has and will continue to happend until we start enforcing the laws aready on the books...

This has nothing to do with religion, we shouldn't support something that is illegal. I have no problem with people coming to the US to live, all I ask is they do it legally... If they want to break our laws, then when they get caught they must pay the price... "

morebrainsthanIneed wrote on May 18, 2008 9:12 PM:

" With you Zekie, there is no need to be more creative. "

Willing worker wrote on May 18, 2008 8:24 PM:

" Ezekiel, come on you know Jesus talked in parables, in stories his listeners could relate to. Therefore what he was talking about was His being the way to the Father, yet the language he used was that of an analogy...a parable if you will. And the analogy he chose to illustrate his point was a simple one. That of entering a sheepfold. Only a thief or a bandit would choose another way other than the gate. Convinced? Okay, still not convinced? How about the Apostle Paul and his admonishments to the early Church in Rome to OBEY the law, the legal authority. That authority is of GOD and that disobeying the law is the same as disobeying GOD. NOW are you convinced...probably not, but you help hone my debating skills. At least you don't resort to hysterical name calling like others in this online community. I enjoy debating with you. I believe you have a sense of humor. Anyway, have a good evening my friend. We'll meet again online. "

Ezekiel wrote on May 18, 2008 7:07 PM:

" worker:

In the context of John 10:1 Jesus is discussing false religious leaders, not people from impoverished countries that are trying to get jobs up here so they can send money to their indigent relatives down South.

It is true that there are some SERIOUS evildoers at work here, specifically the owners of Agriprocessors and the on site management of Agriprocessors.

brains:

You have to be more creative than that! "

superhowy wrote on May 18, 2008 1:46 PM:

" There is a heavy price to pay for not following the law. Shame on Postville for basing their economy on illegal activities. They will surely reap what they sow. I don't feel sorry for most of these folks except for their kids. They all made their choices willingly knowing full well what the consequences would be if they got caught. Hat's off to the government for getting aggressive with this, I have a feeling there are some more communities in the area that need to take note!! "

farmboy wrote on May 18, 2008 10:40 AM:

" it sounds like the writers of this piece are blaming ICE WELL thanks for their effords as we get these people back south of the border where they belong. the writers should go there also as they sure don't like the good old USA. "

Willing worker wrote on May 18, 2008 5:37 AM:

" Jesus said, "Yea I tell you truly, He who enters the sheepfold not by the gate, but climbs in another way is surely a thief and a bandit". John 10:1 Ezekiel, There are many who would have you believe it is unChristian to believe in border security, to believe in the rule of law. I believe the book of John says it best. The Apostle Paul talks of obeying the law of the land in the Epistle to the early Church in Rome when he talks of authority being of GOD and disobeying our legal authorities would be disobeying GOD. Just thought I'd mention the Archbishop's misinterpretations. "

morebrainsthanIneed wrote on May 17, 2008 9:04 PM:

" Go to bed Zekie. Your ideas....Y-A-W-N.. "

Ezekiel wrote on May 17, 2008 2:52 PM:

" The Archbishop said some very good and true things. "

Ezekiel wrote on May 17, 2008 2:10 PM:

" Comrades:

SOCIALISM is the solution! Get rid of the owners of corporations (Like Lenin and old Joe Stalin did with the Bourgueoise in the 1920s) and replace them with government managers. make sure The People have the basics: Free adequate health care, a living wage, adequate housing, strong unions, and a sustainable Central Government energy policy (Nuclear Power with an assist from wind and solar). Even keep some controled Kapitalism in place for incentive purposes. This scenario CAN be done RIGHT NOW with a change in The White House (Obama)/Congress (Democrats & Socialists). It won't happen overnight, but if we outlawed the reactionary tool of the rich Republican Party, then the inexorable forces of change could start to occur. I just hope I live long enough to see The Glorious People's Republic Of America! "

fallen66 wrote on May 17, 2008 10:32 AM:

" Hey Mary Ramos... Postville went to hell the day the illegals showed up!!! "

fallen66 wrote on May 17, 2008 10:30 AM:

" HOORAY FOR I.C.E.!!!!!! "

mnmaniac wrote on May 17, 2008 9:49 AM:

" Why is the news media so extremely pro-illegal immigration?

The bias in the writing is obvious for all to see. "

citizen wrote on May 17, 2008 9:06 AM:

" "With $50,000 monthly payments to make, the company’s loans must be frozen to avoid bankruptcy." Okay, so what's this CRAP all about??? I am a U.S. citizen & if I fell behind on MY monthly payments what would happen to ME?!? I'd loose my property THAT'S what would happen!!!! I sure hope our government officials are listening to us & PLANNING SOME DRASTIC CHANGES AFTER THIS NEXT ELECTION! "

jojodemo wrote on May 17, 2008 8:34 AM:

" For goodness sake people! Here is the perfect time to set a example..fine the stuffing out of the company hiring these Illegals,large enough fines they have to close up. Fine the housing owners hard enough they have to sell out. These "people" are illegal,the children they have ounce here should NOT be the tax payers problem. They should be illegal also! I drive down the roads and travel the country side..I see empty farm house,rough roads,and hear of damaged bridges,etc... Why is the tax payers money going to support illegal immigration and illegal hiring companies when people here at HOME are suffering? Where is the sympathy and help for the working poor and uninsured around here legal? Come On People Wake Up. "

masoncitygirl wrote on May 17, 2008 8:24 AM:

" Here's my stance on it. America used to be a place to welcome everyone in, now we don't want that because there are people willing to work extremely hard for little pay and us americans think we need to work less for more money. I just wish that an immigrant who comes into our country could do it legally. America is making it harder and harder for people to come into our country legally. After all isn't America supposed to be the best and everyone wants to be here? Just something for you to think about. "

willing worker wrote on May 17, 2008 6:10 AM:

" We here in River City could be dealing with this same kind of 'thriving' economy. Former Gov. Vilsack wanted to create a "model city" for welcoming a flood of new Iowans. The problem then was the same as it is now. We are paid poorly here. There is no lack of workers. There is a lack of CHEAP, COMPLIANT labor. Labor willing to accept poor working conditions for lousy wages. My uncle worked at Decker's when I was young. When Decker's became Armour and sold out to Con-Agra he was told his wages would be slashed from $13.50 to $7.00 an hour. He chose early retirement. These illegal aliens then took his job at $5.00 an hour. Do you get it? They are job thieves guilty of identiy theft and social service fraud. Yes the owners of that plant are guilty as h***, but that does not exuse these people who chose to take from us rather than fight to change things for their posterity in their own countries. If this uncontrolled immigration is not stopped WE will become THEM in a corrupt inefficient nation controlled by a wealthy few whose greed will destroy what I served to protect for my grandchildren. "

Registration Required wrote on May 17, 2008 12:11 AM:

" Madonna, do you have the same sympathy for a drug dealer who conducts illegal activity and gets put in jail? What's the difference? These people broke the law too and need to pay!
"

flyguy wrote on May 16, 2008 10:26 PM:

" Is it too much to ask people wishing to immigrate to the US to do so legally? My family came into this country legally 100 years ago, and did what they had to become citizens. These immigrants come here illegally, don't pay taxes, and milk our economy out of everything they can. Our taxes are paying for the housing and healthcare for these moochers. And on top of that, these companies are getting away with importing jobs, without ever leaving the country. They are no better than the companies that close their US factories in favor of ones across the border. "

tribe wrote on May 16, 2008 6:12 PM:

" Since when has "the end justifies the means" become the standard that we live by? Can we as a community,ethnic group,religion,bussiness, or individual pick and choose which laws we wish to obey, and which to ignore? Every article I've read seems to boil the story down to individuals or families. And all are very heart wrenching, but the problem is about 12 million times bigger than these stories portray. If you really want to effect change for these people. Start by asking the question How can it be that you can step over an imaginary line (The US/Mexico border) and go from the most prosporous country in the world to one of the poorest? ONE STEP!!Only the Mexican citizens can make that change ,and not by running away to the US and sending their "slave labor" wages back to THEIR OWN COUNTRY.Sooner or later they will have to stand up and fight for their rights , Also IN THEIR OWN COUNTRY. All I can say is we as Americans should support them in that struggle 100%,but the Mexican people need to innitiate the changes IN THEIR HOME, NOT OURS> "

madonna wrote on May 16, 2008 8:44 AM:

" The reason the landlords didn't say anything is because there's a high probability the illegals were getting gov. rental assistance so the owners had guaranteed rental income. They should be fined as well..... "

tootired wrote on May 16, 2008 8:43 AM:

" mnmaniac--I feel sorry for you for being such a hateful person. I don't know how anyone can not have an ounce of compassion. When it comes to the end, my friend, you will not be the one judging people. "

Venturabats wrote on May 16, 2008 8:29 AM:

" That's a cute little anchor baby in the picture, but that's not what my post is about. I have absolutely no sympathy for the busines owners in Postville that are now losing their monthly income because of this raid:

"Some Hispanic storefronts are shuttered, and homes and apartments are abandoned. At GAL Investments, which owns 127 rental units, Menahn said the vacancy rate soared to 75 percent after Monday’s raid. With $50,000 monthly payments to make, the company’s loans must be frozen to avoid bankruptcy, he added."

They are only getting their due for knowingly leasing to illegal immigrants. Please don't give me the crap that they didn't know the individuals were illegal, ignorance is no excuse!
"

madonna wrote on May 16, 2008 7:16 AM:

" And my sympathy is with the children who have no say so and have now lost the security of a family member/ family unit. I blame their parents. "

madonna wrote on May 16, 2008 7:14 AM:

" Well, Travis Siebert, of course the business was thriving. They didn't have to pay tax on some of the wages. Don't all business owners wish they didn't have to either.......(sarcasm intended) Maybe their business would thrive too.
And the apts. were probably gov. subsidized. So the workers/ families paid cheap rent.
Those are things that legal citizens/immigrants could utilize..NOT ILLEGALS! "

US Citizen wrote on May 16, 2008 7:11 AM:

" “Drive around Iowa and there’s a lot of dead towns,” businessman Gabay Menahn said. “Here it’s the same thing, but we’ve got a heart beating — it’s called Agriprocessors. When you take away the heart, the body dies"

Why should I as a (Legal)taxpayer subsidize any business when they have broken the law and hired illegals.

As far as I am concern I don't have to feel SORRY for those illegals. We have laws in this country to bring in outsiders LEGALLY. You don't do this in Mexico or any other country.

Lets get our heads out of place where the sun don't shine and put a stop to letting this illegals arriving here. Put the troops at the border not in Iraq.

"

KenS wrote on May 16, 2008 7:05 AM:

" I think the Archbishop has pretty much nailed the issue. However I believe our immigration policies are adequate. Over the years, the borders were allowed to be wide open, and it became common place to hire illegals just to keep production moving. Most folks just winked and nodded when it came to documentation, under pressure from upper-management to fill positions. But the employers are just as culpable as the illegals in this case. And I believe this is where we need to focus.

When the Federal Government decided to close the barn door, it was much too late. Raise fines for employing illegal workers to more than just a slap on the hand, include mandatory jail time as well. "

Billy Raymond wrote on May 16, 2008 6:43 AM:

" I feel sorry for people like Ms. Ramos you said..."Postville is going to go to hell,” Well Ms. Ramos if nothing was done about this situation I can assure you that Postville would have surely went to hell in a handbasket. Wake up everyone, these people were and are thieves! And so are the people that knowingly hired them along with the union that wanted them to unionize them.
Thanks! "

Willing worker wrote on May 16, 2008 5:48 AM:

" Archbishop Hanus should have to register as a lobbyist. Where is his concern about the weakest members of OUR society who have suffered as a result of the race to the bottom of the wage scale? Where is his concern for those in Mexico, Guatemala, or any other of a thousand places on this planet? We welcome more immigrants, visa workers, and asylees than the rest of the countries in the world combined. Where is the concern for OUR poor, our sick, our unemployed, or our underemployed. This economy in Postville was built on lies, human trafficking, exploitation, and deciet. It is not what we here in the land of the free and home of the brave should be about. This article asks sympathy for these illegal alien job thieves and perpetrators of fraud. My sympathy is for those who lost employment or whose wages were slashed by these criminals. "

Show 10 latest comments only
Advertisement